The Critique Circle Public Library

The Hobbit
by J.R.R. Tolkien
Amazon rating
Critique Circle rating 
PublisherGraphia
Release Date2002-08-15 (added to CC 2 May 2009)
Amazon Sales Rank1,521
Written for J.R.R. Tolkien"s own children, The Hobbit met with instant critical acclaim when first published more than sixty years ago. Now recognized as a timeless classic with sales of more than 40 million copies worldwide, this introduction to Bilbo Baggins, Gandalf the Wizard, and the spectacular world of Middle-earth tells of the adventures of a reluctant hero, a powerful and dangerous ring, and the cruel dragon Smaug the Magnificent.

Member Reviews
(5 Apr 2016)
A brilliant book. But I think a better edition of that specific one is needed.
(1 Apr 2016)
(25 Dec 2015)
(18 Dec 2015)
(30 Sep 2015)
(3 Jul 2015)
(24 Mar 2015)
(20 Sep 2014)
(19 Jul 2014)
(7 Jul 2014)
(26 May 2014)
I've read this book a number of times, and I read it out loud to my son at least twice. My favorite character would have to be Gollum, of course.
(3 Apr 2014)
(28 Feb 2014)
(27 Feb 2014)
(19 Jan 2014)
(29 Nov 2013)
(19 Oct 2013)
(30 Sep 2013)
(28 Aug 2013)
A perfect introduction to fantasy in its purest and most innocent form. Even the darker characters are charming and leave a lasting impression that you will remember fondly for the rest of your literary life.
Although written as more of a children's book than Lord of the Rings, it has moments that will appeal to a reader of any age. Terror, comedy, tragedy, camaraderie and the birth of fantasy adventure novels as we know them.
(25 Jul 2013)
(21 Jun 2013)
(5 Jun 2013)
(21 May 2013)
(14 Apr 2013)
I think every child should read/ or have this read to them. The Hobbit is an open invitation into your own imagination.
(23 Jan 2013)
(31 Dec 2012)
(30 Dec 2012)
I had not read this as a child so I needed to read it before seeing The Lord of the rings movies. It was well written and contained many details. It was good background information on the characters and plot but did not feel like a prequel.
(17 Dec 2012)
(15 Sep 2012)
(3 Sep 2012)
(27 Jul 2012)
(4 Jul 2012)
(4 Apr 2012)
(5 Jan 2012)
(26 Dec 2011)
(9 Dec 2011)
(23 Nov 2011)
(8 Nov 2011)
(24 Oct 2011)
(16 Oct 2011)
(19 Sep 2011)
(1 Aug 2011)
Having vague recollections from this novel as a child, with wispy mental images of little hobbit holes with little round, green doors, I was looking forward to getting stuck into it as an adult. Given its awesome reputation, the amount I had heard about it and what little I remembered, it could only be an exciting journey through Tolkien’s world. It is a fantasy novel, with wizards and dwarves and elves and many other weird and wonderful creatures. The book follows one Mr Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit on a journey to retrieve some lost treasure with a party of 13 dwarves and the magnificent wizard, Gandalf. The novel details the trials and tribulations upon which they stumble and is littered with action, suspense and many ‘edge of your seat’ moments.

The story itself is a typical children’s action-adventure tale with battles and bravery, dragons and dungeons and ultimately, a happy ending. Their journey consists of enough misfortune to keep the reader excited and interested while at the same time, having plenty of lighter moments – laughter, friendship and achievement – to stop the story becoming relentless and depressing. The world that Tolkien has created is well structured and clearly well thought out. There seems to be little in the way of contradictions or flaws in the way in which his world works or the development of a variety of races. This fantasy is so succinct, in fact, that the book even comes with maps and pictures, languages and songs so that the reader is sure that he is imaging the world as Tolkien had intended. Tolkien’s imagination was clearly an awe-striking and wonderful place, a place in which – if it were to exist in reality – I would love to spend days wandering around, gawping at his magnificent creations and ideas. And, most probably, running in fear for the predominant time I was there.

When I was a child, this book was read aloud to me, by my year 6 teacher Mrs Najar. We did a project on it, I remember drawing a round, green door as my front cover but I’ll admit, I remember little else. Except an underlying feeling of fondness toward the book. As an adult, I myself read it aloud – to my partner. It was a different experience but an equally enjoyable one. This book is definitely good for reading aloud. The narration flows well, the dialogue makes sense without having to see the grammar (a problem which I have found with other books when reading aloud) and the characters have such distinct voices that it is fun to give them different tones, accents and expressions. I imagine that reading this book to a child or group of children would be a lot of fun – making them laugh as you act the grumpy dwarf, become a powerful Elvenking or have the husky voice of the raven Roäc. I would even go so far as to say that for reading aloud, this book is close to perfect. It has everything for the reader to understand and enjoy and even more for the listener to revel in. The only problem I experienced in reading this aloud was the odd missing comma here and there, which meant that a sentence had to be read a couple of times before I could make sense of it. That said, these occasions were few and far between and hardly detracted from our enjoyment at all.

Being a children’s novel, The Hobbit is, of course, layered with meanings, teachings and morals. Throughout, it is littered with small philosophies on life – such as Gandalf’s contemplation of the saying ‘good morning’ and the over-abundance of people saying things they do not mean, or of Bombur’s being overweight and hence, less able to escape trouble. On a larger scale, however, Tolkien gives his thoughts on heroics – the fact that heroes are in fact, just normal folk who have done heroic things and that even you, the reader, an ‘average joe’, could turn out to be a hero too. That you, the reader, could also do magnificent things and have exciting adventures and that these things are not always things that happens to other people. Tolkien contemplates the need for intelligence and bravery, for forethought and planning in order to get yourself out of sticky situations. He ponders the ideas of generosity and fairness as values by which to live your life, as values by which to keep peace. He deliberates the concepts of sharing and reviles demonstrations of greed. Not only has he created a world complete with it’s own places, races and language but he has offered a view on ethics, philosophy and a template by which to live your life.

Even today, given that I only finished the book yesterday, I am
remembering it with a strange sense of nostalgia, a certain feeling of affection and an almost over-whelming desire to visit Bilbo and gang again. Thus, this book comes highly recommended – not only by me but also by the thousands who have read it already and, no doubt, the thousands who will read it in the future. So read it. Read it to your children, to your partner or just to yourself. But read it today, read it aloud and read it with pleasure.
(28 Jul 2011)
(5 Jul 2011)
(1 Apr 2011)
(31 Jan 2011)
(13 Nov 2010)
Does it get any better than this. A template for all to follow.
(22 Oct 2010)
(13 Jul 2010)
(14 Apr 2010)
Beautifully written for a book of that time. There was a lot of humor incorporated in the page, especially the part of the three trolls and the giant spiders in Mirkwood.
(21 Jan 2010)
(20 Dec 2009)
(17 Sep 2009)
(1 Aug 2009)
(8 May 2009)
(2 May 2009)
Other books on CC by the author



Member submitted content is © individual members.
Other material is ©2003-2017 critiquecircle.com
Back to top